Keratin or Protein: How to Choose Your Best Hair Fix

Dry, frizzy, or brittle hair? You’re not alone. Between heat styling, coloring, and environmental exposure, your strands endure daily stress. Choosing the right repair treatment can transform your hair’s health, strength, and shine. But when it comes to keratin vs protein treatments, how do you know what your hair actually needs? Let’s break it down, with insights backed by scientific studies and expert advice.

What Is a Keratin Treatment?

Keratin is the fibrous protein naturally found in hair, skin, and nails, responsible for strength and elasticity. Damage from chemical treatments, UV exposure, and heat styling can degrade keratin, leaving hair weak and frizzy. A keratin treatment replenishes hair with hydrolyzed keratin — small protein fragments that penetrate the hair shaft, seal the cuticle, and smooth the surface.

A study published in the International Journal of Trichology (2015) found that hydrolyzed keratin significantly increased tensile strength and reduced breakage in chemically damaged hair. Read the study.

Expert-Approved Keratin Product Picks

Olaplex No.3 Hair Perfector

Why we recommend it: Although not a traditional keratin treatment, Olaplex uses patented bond-building technology that repairs disulfide bonds, complementing keratin’s smoothing effects and improving hair resilience after chemical damage.

How to use: Apply to damp hair, leave for 10-30 minutes, then shampoo and condition as usual.

Buy Olaplex No.3 Hair Perfector

Keratin Complex Infusion Therapy Replenisher

Why we recommend it: A lightweight leave-in treatment that helps prolong keratin smoothing results while reducing frizz and adding shine between salon visits.

How to use: Apply to towel-dried hair and blow-dry for best results.

Buy Keratin Complex Infusion Replenisher

Brazilian Blowout Acai Deep Conditioning Masque

Why we recommend it: Combines keratin and antioxidants to restore strength and seal the cuticle, leaving hair softer and smoother after heat or color damage.

How to use: Apply to clean, damp hair, leave on for 10-20 minutes, then rinse thoroughly.

Buy Brazilian Blowout Acai Masque

DIY Keratin Treatment (Budget-Friendly)

Why this works: Coconut milk contains natural lauric acid and proteins that mimic keratin’s smoothing properties. Honey provides moisture, while aloe vera soothes the scalp.

Ingredients: 1/2 cup coconut milk, 1 tbsp honey, 2 tbsp aloe vera gel

How to use: Mix well. Apply to clean, damp hair. Leave on for 30 minutes under a shower cap. Rinse with cool water and a gentle shampoo.

What Is a Protein Treatment?

Protein treatments contain hydrolyzed proteins (such as keratin, wheat, silk, or soy) that bind to the hair shaft and fill in microscopic gaps caused by damage. Unlike keratin treatments that focus on smoothing the outer layer, protein treatments rebuild the hair’s internal structure.

A study in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology (2010) demonstrated that protein treatments significantly improved elasticity and resilience of chemically damaged hair, reducing breakage and restoring strength. Read the study.

Expert-Approved Protein Product Picks

Aphogee Two-Step Protein Treatment

Why we recommend it: A salon-grade intensive protein system that’s ideal for severely damaged or overprocessed hair, offering one of the most effective at-home protein reconstructions.

How to use: Apply Step 1, dry until hair hardens, rinse, and follow with Step 2 moisturizer.

Buy Aphogee Two-Step Protein Treatment

Briogeo Don’t Despair, Repair! Deep Conditioning Mask

Why we recommend it: Provides a balanced protein-moisture blend that strengthens without stiffness, ideal for ongoing maintenance of damaged hair.

How to use: Apply to wet hair post-shampoo, leave on for 10 minutes, then rinse thoroughly.

Buy Briogeo Mask

Redken Extreme Anti-Snap Leave-In

Why we recommend it: Lightweight formula that reinforces weakened areas of the hair and protects against future breakage, great for daily use on fragile ends.

How to use: Apply to damp hair, focusing on mid-lengths and ends. Do not rinse.

Buy Redken Anti-Snap

DIY Protein Treatment (Budget-Friendly)

Why this works: Egg is a rich natural source of protein, while plain yogurt provides additional protein and lactic acid for gentle cleansing.

Ingredients: 1 egg, 2 tbsp plain yogurt

How to use: Whisk together and apply to damp hair. Leave on for 20 minutes under a shower cap, then rinse with cool water and shampoo thoroughly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do keratin and protein treatments actually work?

Yes. Peer-reviewed studies confirm their ability to strengthen, smooth, and protect hair when used appropriately. Combining both in a balanced regimen can provide optimal results.

Can I use both treatments together?

Yes. Many experts recommend alternating keratin and protein treatments or using them together in moderation for a well-rounded hair repair plan.

How often should I apply them?

Keratin treatments last 8-12 weeks; protein treatments are typically used every 1-2 weeks depending on hair needs.

What’s the risk of overuse?

Too much protein can make hair brittle, while excessive keratin buildup may weigh hair down. Balance with moisturizing masks and listen to your hair’s response. Explore our top moisture masks.

Further Reading

• Best Hair Masks for Damaged Hair
• Ingredient Guide for Damaged Hair
• International Journal of Trichology: Keratin Study
• Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology: Protein Treatments